Follow @JarlingsCustard

Pies & Cakes

We have a variety of Pies and Cakes available. These are some of our typical varieties, however custom pies and cakes can be ordered in just about any way you want. Orders must be placed at least 24 hours in advance.


Pies

All pies have our signature Cold Fudge under the Custard on the crust unless stated otherwise. Most Pies have Vanilla Custard.


strawberry delight pie

Strawberry Delight Shown Above


Illini

Crushed Butterfinger® and Caramel with Hard Shell Chocolate on top.

Snickerette

Crushed Peanuts and Caramel with Hard Shell Chocolate on top.

Heath® Crackle

Crushed Heath®: and Caramel with Hard Shell Chocolate on top.

Crunch Crackle

Crushed Crunch® and Caramel with Hard Shell Chocolate on top.

Kit Kat® Crackle

Crushed Kit Kat&re; and Caramel with Hard Shell Chocolate on top.

Tortoise

Butterscotch with large Chopped Almonds.

Banana Split

Bananas, Strawberries, Pineapple, and Cherries with Hard Shell Chocolate.

Strawberry Delight

Chocolate, Vanilla, and Strawberry Custard with Crushed Almonds and Strawberry topping.

Raspberry Delight

Chocolate, Vanilla, and Lemon Custard with Crushed Almonds and Raspberry topping.

German Chocolate

Butterscotch, Coconut, and Large Almonds over Chocolate Custard.

Mud

Marshmallow topping and Large Almonds over Chocolate Custard

Almond Joyful

Large Almonds, Coconut, and Hard Shell Chocolate



Snowstorm Pies

mint chocolate chip snowstorm pie

Most of our Snowstorms can be made into a pie. Some popular example are:


Cakes

white cake with lemon and raspberry

Our Cakes are an 8" round cake. They are sliced in half and have custard in the middle, about an inch thick. Cakes feed 6-8 depending on serving size.

Cakes are available with either Chocolate or White Cake.

Cakes can be filled with either plain Custard, or with one of our Snowstorms.